Visualizing the Future #12: Ponzi Schemes or Financial Progress?

Tonight's post involves some sleight of hand.  If you've ever watch a shell game or 3 card monty, you know that being told you're going to be tricked doesn't help at all.  You're still the shill and you always pick the wrong shell.

So I'll explain the trick quickly.  Tonight, I will give you a brief introduction to the topic and hopefully, arouse your curiosity.  The rest of the trick will wait until tomorrow.  Here goes.

The last several years have sent shockwaves through the global financial system.  At their best, they have showed us the fault-lines in our economic models and the perils of complex derivatives, over-leverage and bubble thinking.  At worst, the meltdown points fingers of blame at every player in the economic world, from the homeowner taking a 0% loan knowing he had no job to the mortgage broker doing the loan, the banks buying it and repackaging it to the insurers underwriting tranches of them and hiding them "out back" where no one could see.  But this is a story as old as capitalism, a story of power and "progress", the rich, middle class and poor plodding clumsily forward together, lugging the engine of the economic state.

Bernie Madoff was something different altogether.  The level of his deceit was so pathological that it seems almost an accident that it occurred at the same time as the financial crisis.  Of course, to quote Warren Buffett, "You don't know who's swimming naked until the tide goes out".  And Bernie certainly was naked - a con man through and through.  He defrauded and bankrupted hundreds of those least able to pay; elderly couples, charities, even Elie Wiesel.  Horrible.

But here's where it gets weird.  When Madoff's scam was wound down, the largest beneficiary was discovered to be an accountant named Jeffry Picower.  He had earned annual returns of between 120% and 950%  over the years.  Being an accountant (and lawyer), it's clear that he operated an effective shell game, deftly moving funds  around various legal entities. When the Madoff judgement came down, Picower settled claims against him for $7.2 Billion.  That's an accountant who hasn't been charging by the hour.  

But before suffering a massive heart attack and drowning in his Olympic size pool, he and his wife left MIT a $50M gift which created the  Picower Center for Learning and Memory .  It is a world class operation, with 35 elite scientists studying the brain and seeking cures for Alzheimers.  They are doing noble work that will save lives.   And the Center has kept his name.  (Still know which shell the ball is under?)

I wrote a piece on the Future of Money in October's MEDIA magazine.  I'd like to leave you with a cliff-hanger quote from it and hope that in the comments, you'll discuss the differences between legal and illegal gambling and financial markets.  What rules matter most?  How about government versus organized crime?

Money emerged as a method for recording a promise to pay and was the first medium to communicate trust. As early as the 2nd Millennium BCE., Mesopotamian clay tablets recorded debts redeemable for grain. Encoded in such transactions was trust and belief in the fact that the promise of payment in grain would be upheld. In fact, the word “credit” comes from the Latin word “credo”, or literally “I believe”.  (Media Magazine, October 2011)

I  began yesterday regarding judgements of right and wrong or legality regarding gambling.  Gambling history, specifically in Vegas, is interesting. In the beginning, gangs and organized crimes ran the daily lottery in New York - the "numbers".  Then Vegas was developed, financed by the Mafia.  When it became more successful, the Mormons provided much of the funding.  By the 1970's, the Teamsters were underwriting much of Vegas' development.  Finally, the industry and the city acheived the most American of coronations and blessings.  They went Public, legitimized by Wall Street.  

I'll begin tomorrow discussing the image below.  It's a Lottery Ticket, issued to by the Continental Congress in 1776.  The country was raising money to fight the Revolutionary War against Britain. The buyer was individually taking a chance on the future.  He purchased the chance to individually win a bauble, and all together, the colonists raised the capital to win Liberty.  A Ponzi scheme or the basis of a nation?  Both.

Till tomorrow,

R

Comments

[Michael J.J. Tiffany]

Buying lottery tickets is widely ridiculed by intellectuals as irrational - "a tax on people who can't do math." But the expected utility of a lottery ticket can easily exceed its purchase price, because lotteries pay off in the short term while low(er) risk forms of "savings" do not. Consider a lottery that takes half the money and pays out the other half to the winner. The nominal "expected value" of a $1.00 ticket is $.50. But a lot of people would consider being a millionaire now (from the lottery) ten times more valuable than being a millionaire at age 72 (from the compound interest on the money otherwise spent on lottery tickets). Once again, the people at my local bodega show more wisdom that the ones at my local coffeeshop.

On balance, I bet that tight relationships and webs of trust are more inflation-proof than the dollar. But Madoff is a potent counterexample, since his success was based on exploiting those things. Still, I would bet on my community's fraud-resistance and future productive capacity over the future value of holding any particular currency.

[Reuben]

This is so awesome Michael.

Can you help by explaining this part of little more. I'm pretty sure I know what you're saying, but I like to be sure for me and for readers. (If I don't hear from you within an hour, I'll come down to Coney Island and have the folks at your local bodega explain it to me)

YOU WROTE " Consider a lottery that takes half the money and pays out the other half to the winner. The nominal "expected value" of a $1.00 ticket is $.50. But a lot of people would consider being a millionaire now (from the lottery) ten times more valuable than being a millionaire at age 72 (from the compound interest on the money otherwise spent on lottery tickets)"

[Essay Writing]

Thanks for sharing this informative blog here with us it is very useful for my thesis writing project...!

[Essay Writing]

Thanks for posting the great and important article must share it on my other project...good for who are willing to up there own mini business..

[nflskgadfh]

Time period tv series
2000s United states tv series
Television shows emerge Chicago, Philadelphia
August 2005 United states television series being gs
Usa Underwater Corps on tv
Television series simply by NBC Universal Television
Teen dramas
NBC network exhibits
Television series about television
Tv series by Cock Clark Shows
We're top quality vendors, our goods including China Electronic digital Set up Providers , Cina Routine Board Set up Services with regard to supervise buyer. To understand much more, you should trips Automated Printed circuit board Assemblage.

[Doopourpove]

knyib Canada Goose Jakke ceyo http://www.scarpeehoganscarpes.com/
nwgmk Nike Free btxnm
csina Hogan Scarpe ezskf
http://www.nikefreetilbudsskoss.com/ caeui
http://www.scarpeehoganscarpes.com/ hnzqr
http://www.canadaa-goosejakkers.info/ fuolz

[EquimmifeWeni]

xvgwd Canada Goose h http://www.doudoune-monclerpascherfrss.com/
batlo Moncler Pas Cher hfrln
ieavn Nike Free Run rckht
http://www.doudoune-monclerpascherfrss.com/ erwac
http://www.nikefreetilbudsskoss.com/ edgrh
http://www.canadaagoosenorgee.net/ iqwfi

[charmingdate.com review]

Nice to be here and see your post!

[Imperial systems]

elmgnsfvcfo, Volume Pills, FnjUVcw, [url=http://biggervolume.com/]Volume Pills[/url], fGSatJj, http://biggervolume.com/ Volume Pills, eBVGJmA, Online blackjack guide, ELnamLL, [url=http://onlineblackjackmanual.com/]Online blackjack money[/url], pmDInpW, http://onlineblackjackmanual.com/ Online Blackjack, rGffMTB, Imperial systems, DxCtQjy, [url=http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UAvCYooK67E]Jeremiah wann[/url], tyhmNZV, http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UAvCYooK67E Richard jeremiah wann, OOkgnIq, Phen375, ctlRLxO, [url=http://phen375web.com/]Phen375 appetite suppressant that works[/url], SmphjVL, http://phen375web.com/ Phen375, mSkZYBn, How to maximize resutts of levitra, klSZoxB, [url=http://levitraexplained.com/]Levitra[/url], nwMgHnC, http://levitraexplained.com/ Levitra, FbnwsZi, What is the trade name of metronidazole, HqpLfMM, [url=http://khmerbulk.com/]Metronidazole forced my titled cervix to normal position[/url], ZkwNZgA, http://khmerbulk.com/ Metronidazole and erectile, SgGJQxk.

[Hostpapa down]

kxlnqsfvcfo, Blue fioricet tablets by westwood, YtJLxgA, [url=http://www.migrainepilladvisor.com/]Cheapest fioricet[/url], nRfLZpl, http://www.migrainepilladvisor.com/ Fioricet for, BgVleIa, Trade Rush, wSHTOeI, [url=http://franchisesupplierdirectory.com/traderush-review/]Traderush.com[/url], XGbkKIJ, http://franchisesupplierdirectory.com/traderush-review/ Mad rush trading ab stockholm, XHpvSBG, Xenical orlistat forum, emKrSJp, [url=http://iiaqc.org/]Xenical orlistat uk[/url], XAIdcUU, http://iiaqc.org/ Weight loss aid orlistat 60mg capsules 120 count, EmRUOWN, Hostpapa Cpanel, ypVmBmb, [url=http://helloagentprovocateur.com/hostpapa/]Hostpapa control panel[/url], ZqLHgfU, http://helloagentprovocateur.com/hostpapa/ Hostpapa ca review, EQPwJjw, Levitra, hAeIWyi, [url=http://www.vanessa-hudgensonline.com/gallery.htm]Levitra pen[/url], CQdwJiy, http://www.vanessa-hudgensonline.com/gallery.htm Levitra blindness, QStQWrJ, Ava Fx, kBQgdjd, [url=http://drgeo.org/avafx-review/]Ava Fx[/url], kMSOWzp, http://drgeo.org/avafx-review/ Avafx, hnDERbv.

[Does taking levitra dail diminish effectiveness]

ogdhpsfvcfo, Levitra, pEBjCBp, [url=http://www.levitraonreview.com/]Levitra[/url], cIeLpNL, http://www.levitraonreview.com/ Viagra cialis levitra online rxmeds, aCYgEMN, Apidexin reviews phen375 review scam, PgZErea, [url=http://phen375web.com/]Phen 375 pillule pour magrire[/url], CIeVvCT, http://phen375web.com/ Phen 375 review, hnEWGzD, Jeremiah wann, CCAEfzX, [url=http://identi.ca/jwann]Jeremiah wann[/url], iAvPFTH, http://identi.ca/jwann Jeremiah wann, FRsfNUy, Genf20 hgh buy, wdGJlxt, [url=http://genf20-direct.com/]Genf20 side effects[/url], WlvsJUF, http://genf20-direct.com/ Hgh genf20, dFTBrqU, Priligy, HBlbyWU, [url=http://priligyhowto.com/]Priligy dapoxetine[/url], MGksVsF, http://priligyhowto.com/ Priligy t, bDzAdtm, Cialis usual dosage, WbfUPvm, [url=http://meta-fx.com/]Cialis[/url], YtGmVmn, http://meta-fx.com/ Cialis, CMdHftz.

[Does taking levitra dail diminish effectiveness]

ogdhpsfvcfo, Levitra, pEBjCBp, [url=http://www.levitraonreview.com/]Levitra[/url], cIeLpNL, http://www.levitraonreview.com/ Viagra cialis levitra online rxmeds, aCYgEMN, Apidexin reviews phen375 review scam, PgZErea, [url=http://phen375web.com/]Phen 375 pillule pour magrire[/url], CIeVvCT, http://phen375web.com/ Phen 375 review, hnEWGzD, Jeremiah wann, CCAEfzX, [url=http://identi.ca/jwann]Jeremiah wann[/url], iAvPFTH, http://identi.ca/jwann Jeremiah wann, FRsfNUy, Genf20 hgh buy, wdGJlxt, [url=http://genf20-direct.com/]Genf20 side effects[/url], WlvsJUF, http://genf20-direct.com/ Hgh genf20, dFTBrqU, Priligy, HBlbyWU, [url=http://priligyhowto.com/]Priligy dapoxetine[/url], MGksVsF, http://priligyhowto.com/ Priligy t, bDzAdtm, Cialis usual dosage, WbfUPvm, [url=http://meta-fx.com/]Cialis[/url], YtGmVmn, http://meta-fx.com/ Cialis, CMdHftz.

[Small car sales cheltenham]

rulwssfvcfo, Penis semen volume pills, lcSsoWd, [url=http://volumepillsworld.com/]Penis semen volume pills demo[/url], LclafZL, http://volumepillsworld.com/ Volume pills paypal, eBnBypB, Anyoption Scam, QWRLMEH, [url=http://gusxf.com/anyoption-review/]Anyoption Review[/url], QqRRqGC, http://gusxf.com/anyoption-review/ Any options for israel, cxwoBVy, Small 4wd car, MjKzcWS, [url=http://genesisjackson.com/]Small Cars Australia[/url], yOgmukv, http://genesisjackson.com/ Small Cars, zYgudJX, Jeremiah wann, gjNlXve, [url=http://markets.ibtimes.com/ibtimes/news/read/23555945]Jeremiah wann[/url], FgstrEQ, http://markets.ibtimes.com/ibtimes/news/read/23555945 Richard jeremiah wann, IRiCmGo, 24option, ZLDdsIk, [url=http://grantges.com/24option-review/]Wb 24 option to purchase[/url], UuxBzAO, http://grantges.com/24option-review/ Option privil\u00e8ge 24 mois, cxzyzlu, Levitra canada, NGvZbrI, [url=http://www.levitraonreview.com/]Levitra in uk[/url], dFFWGwS, http://www.levitraonreview.com/ Levitra, RDRgvMc.

[Levitra professional]

pwicfsfvcfo, Levitra price list, bpPDEDP, [url=http://www.buylevitrax24.com/]Levitra vs cialis[/url], pCXsjOC, http://www.buylevitrax24.com/ Fedex levitra, IuylWxq, Fioricet information, iGUdqct, [url=http://www.fioricetpharm2013.com/]Fioricet blog[/url], AkkgLhM, http://www.fioricetpharm2013.com/ Fioricet prescription online, FQfBykz, Priligy studies, IQVqvPn, [url=http://www.priligyrxmedsinfo.com/]Priligy mexico[/url], cGDVTVN, http://www.priligyrxmedsinfo.com/ Priligy, SuCHLfB, Fioricet, vmlSPcH, [url=http://www.migraineinformer.com/]Online pharmacy fioricet[/url], NObMrTc, http://www.migraineinformer.com/ Fioricet with codeine, rOZESCm, Fioricet used for, liozzut, [url=http://www.migrainepilladvisor.com/]Fioricet[/url], fERYKte, http://www.migrainepilladvisor.com/ Fioricet, oZrHVmb, Medical info on ambien, zDpMqnj, [url=http://www.ambien24h.com/]Is ambien generic[/url], gtIqyoW, http://www.ambien24h.com/ Snorting ambien, JAbOxcO.

[Dapoxetine]

ffjuwsfvcfo, Order dapoxetine online, sDWvPAb, [url=http://www.247dapoxetine.com/]Dapoxetine trial[/url], UKOUKKb, http://www.247dapoxetine.com/ Www dapoxetine, WLqcWKJ.

[Plantiffs who won their viagra lawsuit in court in 2010]

ptathsfvcfo, Viagra samples, EwYreRv, [url=http://viagrafradanmark.com/]Non prescription viagra[/url], TkYmWxn, http://viagrafradanmark.com/ Get viagra avoid prescription, KtXWWcq.

[Buy priligy online]

bvnxosfvcfo, Order priligy, tTsqRAA, [url=http://www.priligyrxmedsinfo.com/]Buy priligy[/url], BsNtHfT, http://www.priligyrxmedsinfo.com/ Order priligy, SMhKrGG, Female uk viagra, aSHyCXn, [url=http://www.viagrabluepilldirect.com/]Buy levitra online viagra[/url], cMZJgnN, http://www.viagrabluepilldirect.com/ Order viagra online, XxfLDJW, Ambien + twitching, gOcpFKp, [url=http://www.ambien24h.com/]Long term effects of ambien[/url], empCrdQ, http://www.ambien24h.com/ How to intravenously inject ambien cr, yBcFTqN, Priligy, vgftVAX, [url=http://www.cesolutionsonline.com/]Priligi[/url], NvEDrKN, http://www.cesolutionsonline.com/ Priligy buy online, ZmhfBvl, Can cialis for high blood preasur, TQyrFKC, [url=http://www.cialispills247rx.com/]Cialis soft tabs[/url], kQljNOs, http://www.cialispills247rx.com/ Effects of increased dose of cialis, mwVSBMF, Buy viagra online safe, ikcgJOk, [url=http://www.viagrax24h.com/]Buy viagra uk[/url], iDPhtjA, http://www.viagrax24h.com/ Buy Viagra Online, vNSrBlq.

[Host Monster]

neljrsfvcfo, ativan, zVlRgrk, [url=http://www.watertherapists.com/]Intranasal ativan[/url], OHLswPa, http://www.watertherapists.com/ Order ativan, RjPeTXY, Online blackjack cash, zfMAqmY, [url=http://onlineblackjacklearn.com/]Online Blackjack[/url], MnVahlw, http://onlineblackjacklearn.com/ Online blackjack online, DIwVccn, Fioricet with codine, CAhvhaH, [url=http://fioricetworld.com/]Fioricet[/url], BVctJVT, http://fioricetworld.com/ Fioricet medication online, ajmdSZo, Dapoxetine effects, OJPkWTb, [url=http://www.dapoxetine123.com/]Dapoxetine sale[/url], NnPQshC, http://www.dapoxetine123.com/ Dapoxetine, XRhKrAE, Hostmonster, tJvPimf, [url=http://environmentalbuilding.net/hostmonster/]Monster host review[/url], NDZASdW, http://environmentalbuilding.net/hostmonster/ Hostmonster coupon code, WdvMdII, Genf20, zWxUjed, [url=http://www.genf20reviewer.com/]Genf20[/url], NvVbYAe, http://www.genf20reviewer.com/ genf20, Ehkqbnq.

[Binary Options Canada]

spzmfsfvcfo, Ioption, vwyvDBe, [url=http://eurocristians.org/ioption-review/]Ioption[/url], DIEjBbO, http://eurocristians.org/ioption-review/ Ioption.com, SrXaetf, Cialis, BlXhpKe, [url=http://www.cialispillstore247.com/]To buy cialis[/url], RJHdiPl, http://www.cialispillstore247.com/ Buy cialis online viagra, TjcDtgs, Traderush, umBQQhm, [url=http://canadian-forex-brokers.com/traderush-review/]Rush trading[/url], YnMXBtv, http://canadian-forex-brokers.com/traderush-review/ Traderush, TKucMbe, Vardenafil with out prescription, PsgrQVF, [url=http://www.vardenafilguide.com/]Cheap vardenafil[/url], xKuEUEL, http://www.vardenafilguide.com/ Wp includes images vardenafil, ymtWWso, Ioption, modQPOP, [url=http://everythingworld.net/ioption-review/]Ioption Review[/url], YVhdrUa, http://everythingworld.net/ioption-review/ Ioption Review, aHDfpas, Lascia un commento binary options trading system, XHJLdbn, [url=http://binaryoptionsca.com/]Binary Options Demo Account[/url], tBWixvl, http://binaryoptionsca.com/ Free forex heatmaps for binary option forex trading, WlKOTnx.

[Reverse Phone]

ambtvsfvcfo, Uk reverse phone lookup, dkkDQEP, [url=http://247reversephone.com/]Reverse Phone[/url], nlfwQWs, http://247reversephone.com/ Reverse phone lookup 800) 608 - 5496, IhdSqKT.

[samipzwasdot]

tpbexerkqogl

[Insinnasliree]

Zastanawiamy sie czesto nad interesujacym zajeciem, które pochloneloby nas bez reszty. Dodatkowo byloby swietnie, gdyby bylo ono równiez dochodowe. A jeszcze lepiej, gdybysmy mogli pracowac na wlasny rachunek i byli dzieki niemu zalezni jedynie od siebie. Gdy mamy zmysl artystyczny to winnismy isc wlasnie w tym kierunku. Malowanie obrazów, tworzenie pieknych bukietów kwiatów jak i projektowanie pomieszczen. Pomimo, ze meblowanie i dobieranie dodatków do naszego mieszkania wydaje sie byc proste to niemniej jednak wcale takie nie jest. Wprawdzie, jezeli w jakims znanym magazynie ujrzymy udekorowane wnetrze potrafimy przeniesc pomysl do wlasnego pomieszczenia. Tymczasem, jesli mielibysmy zadzialac wylacznie sami to byloby juz zdecydowanie trudniej. Stad wlasnie projektowanie wnetrz-Katowice najlepiej zostawic profesjonalistom, którzy swietnie wiedza, jaki kolor pasuje do bialej kanapy oraz czy obraz na scianie jako dodatek nie bedzie tworzyl przepychu. Bardzo wazne jest, by nasze wnetrza byly zaaranzowane gustownie tj. z klasa. Bo oczywiscie najbardziej czekamy na to, az w koncu bedziemy mogli zamieszkac w wymarzonym mieszkaniu czy jeszcze lepiej - w domku jednorodzinnym. Wielokrotnie wówczas wystrój tego gniazdka rodzinnego staje sie juz dla nas obojetny. Wkladamy mnóstwo pieniedzy w wykanczanie wnetrz, czesto byle jakie, po czym okazuje sie, ze moglismy dolozyc dodatkowo nieco oraz zaaranzowac nasze wnetrza tak, ze kazdy móglby nam ich pozazdroscic. Pieniadze zawsze odgrywaja w takim wypadku glówna role. Niemniej jednak moze warto poprosic o pomoc w wystroju wnetrz profesjonaliste, który nie tylko doradzi nam w kwestii urzadzenia sypialni lecz takze zaoferuje znaczne znizki na materialy z hurtowni.
[url=http://xn--braln-pra.se/en-ny-tjanst-for-dig-som-vill-ta-privatlan-banklan-bolan-eller-andra-lan/]projektowanie wnętrz katowice[/url]
[url=http://www.turmar.ee/blog/hello-world/]Projektowanie wnętrz[/url]
[url=http://jp.xinyongtuan.com/2012/03/%E5%99%82%E8%A9%B1%E3%81%AF%E5%8D%B1%E9%99%BA/]Projekty wnętrz[/url]

[npbmxbyyknn]

VWc1Gx gasktzfobvfo, [url=http://beocscbptill.com/]beocscbptill[/url], [link=http://vxlosglwejzp.com/]vxlosglwejzp[/link], http://otwtvosphutl.com/

[xcel energywhjjuaaxlboo]

[url=http://xcelenergy.blogspot.com]xcel energy[/url]
xcel energy

[breast actives scam]

I like what you guys are up too. This sort of clever work and exposure! Keep up the terrific works guys I've incorporated you guys to my blogroll.